A Toronto-based non-profit, the EJB Steinberg Arts Foundation, has facilitated the return of Pierre-Auguste Renoir’s 1908 sketch Le Jugement de Pâris to the Musée d’Orsay in Paris, following a complex history of ownership and alleged Nazi looting. The foundation acquired the artwork in 2023 and loaned it to the museum as part of an exhibition showcasing Renoir’s lesser-known works. The sketch depicts a mythological scene involving the Trojan prince Paris and the three goddesses Hera, Athena, and Aphrodite. Originally owned by art dealer Ambroise Vollard, the sketch fell into Nazi hands during World War II and was later confiscated by the French government. In July 2023, France enacted a law requiring the restitution of cultural property, leading to the auction of the sketch, which the foundation successfully purchased. Elen Steinberg, the foundation’s director, emphasized the significance of making such important artworks publicly accessible.
Why It Matters
The return of Le Jugement de Pâris highlights ongoing efforts to address the historical injustices of art looted during World War II, particularly from Jewish collectors. Art dealer Ambroise Vollard’s collection, which included thousands of pieces, was unlawfully sold after his death, reflecting the chaotic art market during the Nazi occupation of France. France’s 2023 law mandating restitution of cultural assets underscores a growing recognition of the need to return artworks to their rightful owners or descendants, promoting accountability and cultural heritage preservation. The case also illustrates the complexities of provenance research in the art world, where many works remain unaccounted for due to historical upheavals.
