France’s move to establish an EU-wide ban on the export of second-hand clothes is closely monitored by numerous African countries that receive millions of tons of such clothing annually.
The French national assembly recently passed a law that would phase in fines of up to €10 per item by 2030 and prohibit advertising for these products.
The French environment ministry aims to propose a discussion on an EU ban at an upcoming meeting of EU environment ministers, supported by Sweden and Denmark, with the message that “Africa must no longer be the dumping ground for fast-fashion.”
Data from the United Nations reveals that the EU exported 1.4 million metric tons of used textiles in 2022, with a significant portion ending up in African and Asian countries, leading to environmental concerns.
While the new law is presented as a way to address textile waste and environmental harm, a ban on exporting second-hand clothes could significantly impact African nations, hindering their local textiles industries.
Despite concerns about the quality of imported clothes, the second-hand clothing market provides livelihoods for many market sellers in Africa, with around $1 billion worth of used clothes imported annually, constituting about 30 percent of the global market.
Following the approval of the law in Paris, Chinese fashion company Shein criticized it, warning of potential negative effects on French consumers already facing economic challenges.
The East African Community previously faced trade disputes with the US over second-hand clothing imports, as the EAC believed that a ban could boost domestic clothing manufacturing but faced opposition from the US over trade agreements.
In response to pressure from the US, only Rwanda implemented the ban on second-hand clothing imports, leading to its suspension from the African Growth and Opportunity Act (AGOA), while other countries like Kenya, Tanzania, and Uganda decided against the ban despite accounting for a significant portion of Africa’s used clothing imports.
In Kenya, the second-hand clothes market is substantial, with the industry becoming a prominent issue in the 2022 presidential elections, where candidates debated the implications of a potential import ban.
