The lack of coherence in the plot is not the main issue with “Tommy.” Originally presented as a rock opera in 1969, questions about the story have always been expected, much like with other theatrical works.
The musical aspects, including impressive guitar work and vocal harmonies, are not to be criticized. Transitions to film and stage adaptations have brought additional delights, showcasing talented performers and innovative visuals.
Despite various iterations, the most impactful experience of Pete Townshend’s songs is still when they play out in one’s mind. The album, free from the constraints of literal storytelling, made a significant mark in music history.
Today, audiences may expect more from a musical production than just sensory overload. This particular rendition, directed by Des McAnuff, focuses more on noise and visual effects than on the story itself.
The narrative, set in WWII and its aftermath, may benefit from some ambiguity. The character of Tommy undergoes various transformations, reflecting themes of trauma, celebrity, and reintegration.
While the plot may be hard to follow, viewing “Tommy” as a dream-like experience tied to Townshend’s personal history adds a layer of depth. The show’s tunes and lyrics, born out of Townshend’s own struggles, hold emotional weight when presented thoughtfully.
McAnuff’s interpretation lacks the nuance found in Townshend’s original work, opting instead for a stark and bombastic approach. The production’s emphasis on visual and auditory stimuli overshadows any genuine emotional connection.
Ultimately, “Tommy” in this form may appeal to fans of elaborate rock concerts, but it falls short in capturing the humanity and complexity of Townshend’s music.
The Who’s TommyAt the Nederlander Theater, Manhattan; tommythemusical.com. Running time: 2 hours 10 minutes.
