Around ten years ago, California made history by being the first state in the US to ban single-use plastic bags as a way to address the growing plastic waste issue. However, this move led to the introduction of reusable, heavy-duty plastic bags that were offered to shoppers for a small fee. Despite being designed for multiple uses and technically recyclable, many retailers considered them exempt from the ban.
Unfortunately, these heavy-duty bags didn’t see much reuse as they closely resembled the flimsy bags they replaced. Despite bearing a recycling symbol, very few of them were actually recycled. As a result, last year Californians disposed of more plastic bags, by weight, than before the ban was implemented, according to CalRecycle, California’s recycling agency.
In an attempt to rectify this situation, lawmakers are now proposing a new bill that would ban all plastic bags offered at checkout, including the heavy-duty ones. Shoppers would still have the option to purchase paper bags.
State Senator Ben Allen, a Democrat and sponsor of the bill, stated, “It’s time for us to completely eliminate plastic bags.”
Some experts view California’s initial plastic bag ban as a well-intentioned but failed experiment that inadvertently worsened the situation. Mark Murray, director of Californians Against Waste, mentioned that the exemption for thicker bags was not a concern initially but later became problematic.
The pandemic further exacerbated the issue as concerns over virus transmission led to a surge in the use of thicker plastic bags, often discarded after a single use.
According to the bill’s sponsors, the average time shoppers used a plastic bag was only twelve minutes. Some advocates believe that proper enforcement of the initial ban could have been effective if the plastic bags were actually recycled as mandated.
Jan Dell, founder of The Last Beach Cleanup, has been leading efforts to hold retailers accountable for selling the thicker plastic bags in violation of the ban.
Despite the challenges, Daniel Conway of the California Grocers Association stated that retailers have followed the law and expressed hope that new legislation would address any remaining confusion.
The plastic industry group, America’s Plastic Makers, emphasized their commitment to recycling and urged policymakers to collaborate with companies to prevent unintended negative environmental impacts. Other states, learning from California’s experience, have also implemented plastic bag bans to combat plastic waste.
Despite setbacks, California continues to lead efforts in reducing plastic waste, passing laws to ensure truth in advertising regarding recycling symbols and shifting responsibility for waste disposal to plastic producers.
The state has also begun investigating the role of fossil fuel companies in the plastic waste crisis, with industry groups refuting allegations and focusing on improving recycling rates in the US.
